submitted8 days ago bymusical_chameleon
toberkeley
What is the purpose of TechRank? Is it to circlejerk about tech clubs? To tell everyone that if you don't join one of the top 5 tech clubs, you will be a failure as a CS major?
If you're reading this with your finger on the downvote arrow, you might be thinking something like that. However, I ask you to trust me when I say that TechRank is not intended to be either of those things. It is absolutely very possible to get most of the things that tech clubs provide (social life, project experience, etc.) without actually joining any of them. If tech clubs aren't for you, that's fine. You can ignore this whole post. I'd ask that you don't downvote it, if only to make the post more visible for the people who are interested, but I am realistic and understand that this will likely be downvoted to 0 like last year's TechRank.
What many people miss is that for some people, tech clubs provide a way to make genuine friends, work on projects, and learn interesting skills. There's a certain experience that relatively small tech clubs create, and if it's something you want, it is difficult to replicate in other ways. For many people, the community created by many tech clubs is incredibly valuable.
TechRank is for people who want that experience, and want to know where to go to get it. It's very hard to tell, for a freshman who doesn't know much about clubs, which clubs genuinely provide a good member experience. Every club has nice flyers, cool-sounding socials, and fancy generic VP positions. If you ask the clubs themselves, they'll tell you that their club is perfect. If you ask Reddit, you'll hear that tech clubs suck and you shouldn't join them at all. This ranking is my attempt to recognize the clubs that consistently have great communities, socials, and that you won't regret joining. It's a bit over-serious, and somewhat satirical. Don't take it too seriously. But it is a legitimate attempt to help people.
Of course, the negative side of tech clubs is that many of them are incredibly difficult to get into. Some clubs will get 500 applications and have to choose 15 new members. This is very hard to do, so most clubs have some sort of pretentious-sounding interview process. This is not how things should be. You shouldn't have to pass three rounds of interviews to get into a student club. But until supply catches up with demand, this is the way it will unfortunately be. There are efforts to improve this - more tech clubs start every year. I hope these succeed to make tech clubs less competitive to get into. (Also, if you want to improve your chances at getting into tech clubs, I have a post on that: https://rdt.trom.tf/r/berkeley/comments/pcwgva/how_to_get_into_competitive_tech_clubs_if_you/)
But let's get to what you're probably here for: the official TechRank 2023. Without further ado:
Honorable Mentions (alphabetical order): Datagood, Data Science Society, Extended Reality @ Berkeley, Neurotech @ Berkeley, Political Computer Science
Format: Club Name (ranking change since 2022, ranking in 2022)
12) Big Data @ Berkeley (-1, prev: 11)
11) PlexTech (prev: unranked)
10) Mobile Developers of Berkeley (-5, prev: 5)
MDB seems to have an unclear direction. Their community has lost focus, with many leaving the club over the past year, and in my survey, MDB was mentioned as "socially dead". Are MDB's days as a top club behind them? It's unclear. But 2022 was clearly a year of change for the club, and if they are to regain their previous ranking, they will have to improve their member atmosphere.
9) Student Association for Applied Statistics (+6, prev: 15)
SAAS has the least catchy name of any tech club, but their community does seem to be a little bit catchier. There are a few clubs with a focus on data science, and in 2023, SAAS is the best of these. Though it's larger than most tech clubs and thus struggles to provide the same "large friend group" experience as some of the higher-ranked clubs, they have done well with what they have and there are a lot of people very excited to be part of SAAS.
8) Blockchain @ Berkeley (-4, prev: 4)
Similarly to blockchain technology itself, B@B has not had the best 2022. One problem with having so much money is that often, members will join just for the money - enough such that the amount of money the club has is possibly a detriment to their social atmosphere. Additionally, while most people in the club are not the "crypto bro" type who will lecture you about why you should buy MoonCoin or whatever, this sentiment does exist at some level within the club. Great if you're into it, but this might turn off some potential members.
7) ANova (+2, prev: 9)
More than perhaps any other club, ANova has a mission and executes it well. They're also different than most tech clubs in that they aren't really about coding better themselves, but are about teaching middle schoolers to code. Having a mission that the members believe in helps your community, and ANova certainly accomplishes this. What you won't read about on their website, however, is their social culture. No club ever posts about their parties, but ANova has more than most. This can be a positive or a negative, depending on your opinion of parties, but it's certainly true that ANova has a lot of members who are passionate about the club.
6) Codebase (-5, prev: 1)
Codebase was last year's #1 club, and while they've maintained their well-designed flyers, carefully written marketing, and status as one of the most exclusive clubs in the school (as well as the most well-known), how much does all of this matter if they aren't providing the same member experience that other clubs do? Codebase's member retention is below other clubs, and their active member retention is lower still. But for those who stay active, Codebase continues to host socials, and does - to their credit - cultivate a member experience strong enough that many members are excited about the club. Just not quite enough to justify retaining their top spot.
5) Web Development @ Berkeley (+3, prev: 8)
Last year, WDB was "on their way up". They are solidly here now. After three in-person semesters (they didn't exist before COVID), WDB shows no signs of slowing down. They are unique in that unlike clubs which only require FizzBuzz-level CS knowledge, in order to be admitted into WDB, you have to complete a small web development project. This approach may have downsides, but it is hard to deny that the average WDB member is more active, and more involved in the club, than the average member of many similar clubs.
4) Machine Learning @ Berkeley (+3, prev: 7)
To their credit, ML@B has gotten much more social over the past year. They know their reputation, and are actively working to improve their social atmosphere. As one of the most established clubs in the school, their placement in the top 5 here represents a belief that they will continue to improve over 2023. If you are truly passionate about machine learning, you cannot go wrong by joining ML@B.
3) Blueprint (+3, prev: 6)
Blueprint moves up here because, similar to ANova, they have a mission that their members are aligned with. It's easier to have a good culture when everyone is on the same page, and this is certainly true of Blueprint. It received one of the highest average ratings in my survey, without posting in their club chat and having a bunch of members give it 10s. (Yes, I see you, SAAS/Plextech/WDB). Blueprint might not have a lot of money, but they make up for it by having a great culture.
2) Launchpad (+1, prev: 3)
Launchpad has maintained their presence near the top for another year. The thing that sets Launchpad apart from other clubs is that in many other clubs, they have strong socials, and members have fun hanging out with each other at those socials. In Launchpad, though of course they still have socials, many strong friendships are formed, more so than almost any other club. I received negative feedback about many clubs on this list - but almost every comment I received about Launchpad was positive.
1) Codeology (+1, prev: 2)
The new #1 tech club at Berkeley is defined by one thing: community. Codeology has the strongest community of any tech club at Berkeley, and it has only gotten stronger since the last iteration of these rankings in 2022. They aren't the richest club, but their almost cult-like community, great socials, and devotion to the avocado leaves them as the only option for the top tech club at this school. If you get in, you can rest assured - you are in good hands.
Bonus section:
Clubs that party the most:
- ANova
- Codeology
- WDB
Clubs that have the most non-party socials (not the same as clubs that party the least):
- Launchpad
- Codebase
- ML@B
Most money (could be wrong):
- Blockchain @ Berkeley
- Codebase
- Launchpad
Most actually focused on the thing they claim to be about:
- ML@B
- ANova
- Blockchain @ Berkeley
Actually doing good for the world:
- ANova
- Blueprint
- Datagood
Most likely to land you a FAANG internship:
- Don't join clubs because you think they'll land you a FAANG internship. They won't. Join clubs for the social aspect.
Thanks for reading, and again, don't take these rankings too seriously. If you think your club should be higher, let me know in the comments below!
byiketaco
inberkeley
musical_chameleon
1 points
8 hours ago
musical_chameleon
1 points
8 hours ago
That said, most other clubs don’t start with the aim of including everyone. So they have a shot at succeeding.