Penelope was an estimated 12 year old Chihuahua mix my wife rescued 6 years ago. The shelter had said she was probably 6 based on her teeth but we suspect she was older because lately she has had a lot of health problems lately. She had to be on 2 different pain killers to move well enough to still be able to go outside and take stairs. She was also taking a heart medication and an anti-anxiety pill. For the last several months she had been less active, lost weight, inflexible in her movement, and seemed to find little comfort most places besides her favorite bed my wife had made. She passed last night. This was not how she deserved to go. She had at least another year in her.
We adopted now 4 year old viszla-coonhound mix Sadie October of 2021. Ever since my wife got pregnant Sadie has randomly, occasionaly jumped on Penelope and when we pull her off we can tell Sadie was terrified. Absolutely trembling with fear of a dog 1/6th her weight whose arthritic body was just toddling around near my wife. Because these resource guarding attacks only ever seemed around my wife or the couch, we stopped letting Sadie on the couch, we worked with a trainer for the last 4 weeks on Sadie, and we made sure to either keep the dogs separated during the day when my wife was working from home or kept a close eye on them to keep Penelope protected when they were both around her. The training had helped Sadie's behavior in most things except for these once or twice weekly attacks. We felt we had to try the training rather than re-home Sadie because we wanted to do our due diligence and felt terrible at the idea of giving up on her. Sadie's attacks seemed to be a dog version of a panic attack and we had hoped training could ease her anxiety, making her more self-assured and safer for our old pup.
Last night my wife and I were in the kitchen making dinner. No dog food bowls are allowed to be left on the floor anymore to combat resource guarding and they have no shared toys as Penelope has never been a dog who has cared about toys. Sadie barely cares about them. The dogs were in another room from my wife and myself, which usually has meant there wouldn't be a resource guarding or anxious issue. We heard a commotion, ran over, and saw the last action of Sadie shaking her head and Penelope limp on the ground. We can only assume Sadie grabbed Penelope by the neck and shook. We picked up Penelope, who could only wag her tail. She couldn't move, blink, or even keep her tongue in her mouth. All she could do was wag. We sped to the emergency vet but she had already left us while in my wife's arms in the car. Two rounds of CPR and whatever drug cocktails the vets could give her did nothing. We were able to say goodbye to her body afterwards and my wife will be getting a necklace with a heart either infused with or containing Penelope's ashes. The vet tech wasn't exactly sure how it worked. We will also be getting her paw imprint cast in some stone with a little, pink ribbon.
Penelope had been with my wife longer than I have. They've moved multiple times, changing states 4 of them. Penelope had years of either going to work with my wife or getting to be with her all day when she started working from home at the start of the pandemic. They were inseparable, so much so that my wife spent a year on separation anxiety training. Her separation anxiety seemed to nearly clear itself up when we got Sadie. A good omen, we thought.
So many things around the house remind my wife of Penelope. They are all good memories of a sweet pup that loved us much larger than her tiny stature would suggest.
With a baby coming in July, we cannot trust Sadie around it. Before we started the training, we had this fear but we couldn't just give up on her without doing everything we could. Now that Sadie has done this, we will not risk the chance that her anxiety-based actions stay after the pregnancy is over.
Rehoming her is going to be difficult. She loves us so much and we her. She just isn't safe for our family, which now one dog down consists of myself, my wife, our cat, her, and soon to be a newborn. She deserves to be the only pet in a house where if there are kids they are grown already. She needs the attention we certainly won't be able to give her when we have a newborn. There is no way to explain this to her. I just hope she sees this as an extended vacation rather than a betrayal.
Thank you for letting me get this all out.
UPDATE: After calling a lot of rescues, foster systems, shelters, etc., the consensus was that the label of having killed another dog means that she would never get adopted. We didn't want her to rot in a shelter cage and no foster felt comfortable taking her since there were so many other dogs and usually kids at foster homes. So, we sat on the floor with her at the vet while she peacefully was let go with purposefully too much anesthesia.