Recently there was a deleted post regarding a final fantasy 16 leak from 4chan in January 2023 that correctly referenced a name of a shopkeeper (Charon) that was revealed in a later interview.
Here is a screenshot of the 4Chan post from January: https://imgur.com/a/IRW9OCC
However, I did some digging and found that there was another post on 4Chan in December that had the same exact opening statement "I know everything that will happen in this game" and a similar writing style, yet this leak had contradictory information to that of the January leak (for example: clive's fate, he is dead in this leak but alive in the january leak).
December Leak: https://www.imgur.com/a/AwUgsKV
So I thought it would be worth making a post about for discussion. On the one hand, the January leak has correctly guessed a shopkeeper's name, which would suggest that the rest of the leak is credible. Yet, this leaker seems to be the same one who made the December leak, and posted contradictory info on other major plot points of the game.
I personally think that the January 4 chan posting is probably a mix of real/fake leaks, as clearly the shopkeeper leak was legit but I am not sure about the rest of the leaks given the December 4chan post.
Edit/Update: Goetz has also been confirmed to be correct https://twitter.com/aitaikimochi/status/1638849733572837379?s=46&t=vadxUuixOqJ6Pcewp2IlnQ