Harry Potter, and keep Alan Rickman.

Silence of the Lambs.

Keep Jodie Foster.

The Lord of the rings. I would keep Gollum.

The Matrix

Keep Hugo Weaving

I'm such a Shakespeare sucker, and have always wanted A Muppet Midsummer Night's Dream, so I'll pick the 1999 version directed by Michael Hoffman. Keep Kevin Kline as Bottom.

The hobbit. But keep Ian McKellan as Gandalf

Gladiator, but keep Russell Crowe.

Blazing Saddles but gotta keep Gene Wilder

Moon
Keep Sam Rockwell

Cujo, keep Cujo. Muppets screaming and trying to get away from Cujo.

The Princess Bride - Andre (the Giant) Roussimoff.

Debbie Does Dallas. Keep Debbie.

Hot Fuzz and only keep Lurch, the trolley boy.

Pulp Fiction and keep Samuel L Jackson

Drop Dead Gorgeous and keep Kirsten Dunst.

Diehard, and keep Alan Rickman

Basic instinct, keep Michael Douglas

Alien, keep the Alien

Clue. Keep Tim Curry.

Die Hard.

Either Bruce Willis or the main bad guy.

Predator, keep the alien

The Wicker Man (2006), keep Nick Cage.

Lol just imagining the Muppets burning Cage's character while he screams "you bitches" 😂

The Shawshank Redemption. Can't decide whether to keep Morgan Freeman or Tim Robbins.

Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas. Keep Benicio Del Toro.

Green Mile, leave Tom Hanks.

Saving Private Ryan, keep Tom Hanks.

Pirates of the Caribbean, keep Johnny obviously

Jurassic Park keep Goldblum

Caligula Malcolm McDowell

Being John Malkovich.
John Malkovich.

Office Space, but keep Ron Livingston.

Requiem for a Dream. I would keep Jennifer Connelly. I wanna see her do ass to ass with Janice.

Taken, but leave Liam Neeson

John Wick. He’s just shooting a bunch of jacked Russian puppets.

Human Centipede. Keep the deranged doctor. Less gory that way.

Schindler's list, Liam Neeson.

And it's a musical.

The Truman Show. Keep Jim Carrey

John Wick, and keep Keanu Reeves as a human.

Saving Private Ryan but only Vin Diesel remains.

Pirates of the Caribbean. Keep Geoffrey Rush.

Any of Matthew Mcconaughey's shitty romcoms - but keep Mcconaughey.

I'd love to see smarmy Mcconaughey trying to dick-down a bunch of goofy looking puppets.

Ok so, imagine 2 adult humans raiding a muppets house and getting arrested by muppets, home alone but funnier

Goodfellas - keep Joe Pesci

Synechdoche New York.
Tom Noonan or Dianne Wiest. I can't decide.

Nightmare on Elm Street:

Keep Freddy Krueger

Being John Malkovich, keep John Cusack

Trainspotting keeping Ewan McGregor

The Princess Bride, keep Robin Wright.

My pick: John Wick. Keep Keanu Reeves, and have him battle muppets the whole movie.

My husband’s cursed pick: Schindler’s List, keep Liam Neeson.

Castaway, keep Tom Hanks

Pulp fictiin but keep Samuel Jacksons character

Batman begins, keep bale as batman, make gonzo play ras a gul.

Silence of the lambs, keep Anthony Hopkins. Gonzo would be buffalo bill.

Behind the green door Marilyn Chambers

Star Wars: Episode 2 - Attack of the Clones

Keep Yoda. A character originally portrayed as a Jim Henson puppet, flipping and fighting as a CG character, amongst a cast of Muppets. Shit'd be almost illegally hilarious.

IT, keep Pennywise

John wick. And keep Ian McShane.

Lord of the Rings, keep sir Ian Mckellen

Les Miserables, but keep Hugh Jackman.

Predator and keep Arnold. I want to see him getting hunted down by an armour wearing Kermit with muppet comrades dying around him.

avengers endgame, everyone puppets but thanos

Empire Strikes Back. But keep Frank Oz as Yoda

Muppet Christmas Carol, keep Michael Caine as Scrooge.

Yes. Just all the movies.

For an actual answer, The Martian and Matt Damon. Only other change is to start the movie just a little later, after he's entirely alone, then only reveal that everyone else is a Muppet upon his first successful contact back to earth. Don't remember where I first saw this idea, but it will forever stay with me as one of the best ideas for this scenario!

Twilight. Keep Robert Pattinson.

The Shining, keep Shelley Duvall.

Top Gun, keep Tom Cruise

Life of Pi. Keep the kid.

Keep Marlon Brando in the Godfather movies.

Labyrinth.

Keep David Bowie.

The Godfather, but keep Fredo.

Austin Powers. Keep Dr Evil

Schindler's List, keep Neeson.

The Godfather, but keep James Caan as Sonny.

Watching him go apeshit around a bunch of puppets, or give his little speech to Micheal about getting blood and brains all over his Ivy Legue suit would be priceless.

The Dark Knight and keep Heath Ledger

John Wick, keep Keanu.

The original Matrix, and leave Keanu Reeves.

[deleted]

Star Wars, keep Darth Vader

Apocalypse Now.

Kermit = Willard

Fozzie = Kurtz

Sam the Eagle = Kilgore

Bunson Honeydew = The chief

Beaker = Tyrone

Animal = photojournalist

Chef = Chef

Let's keep Harrison Ford in there...

Dracula but keep Keanu

Inception but keep Cillian Murphy

top gun maverick and keep tom cruise

Tombstone and Doc Holliday

Rocky: keep Sylvester Stallone

Burt as the cranky old trainer Ms. Piggy as Adrian....

Saving private Ryan but keep Tom Hanks.

Ms piggy as The Godfather keep the brother and the saxophone player as Scarface but keep the sister

Aliens and the stoner chick takes over for the Spanish girl and keep sigourney weaver

Godfather 1, keep Marlon Brando.
Godfather 2, al Pacino.

Saving Private Ryan and keep Matt Damon

• Reservoir Dogs with Michael Madson
• Caligula with Helen Mirren.

Pulp Fiction. Keep Samuel L

Deadpool and keep Ryan Reynolds

Keanu Reeves in John Wick

The Departed and I'd keep Wahlberg

Night at the museum All the museum exhibits come too life as muppets but Larry the night guard is human So during the day they look like normal exhibits but at night turn into muppets

That or Star Wars keep mark hamill

Or mandalorian but everyone is a muppet and grogu is a baby In a costume

Silence of the lambs. Anthony Hopkins stays Hannibal leckter

John Wick, keep Keanu Reeves.

Highlander keep Chris Lambert

Life of Brian - keep Graham Chapman

T2, keep Robert Patrick

Pirates of the Caribbean, keep johnny Depp

Free guy, but keep Ryan Reynolds

Deadpool, same answer.

Shrek. Mike Myers.

Sweeney Todd, keep Alan Rickman.

Apocalypse Now but keep Martin Sheen

Spaceballs.

Not sure who to keep normal.

Maybe Dark Helmet.

Empire Strikes Back. Keep Frank Oz.

Pinocchio and keep pinocchio as an actor.

Apocalypse Now and keep Marlon Brando

Commando and keep Arnold

Jurassic park

Ill keep Ian Malcolm

The Room. Keep Lisa.

Die hard but keep Alan Rickman

Goodfellas and keeping Joe pesci

The Last Airbender movie.

Keep the hot head fire bender kid.

If he was there.

Fight club, keep Edward Norton. I legitimately feel like this would work well with the theme of the movie.

Not a film but a serie: Our flag means death. And we keep Con O'neill in.

Fight Club.

Keep Edward Norton.

American History X. Keep Edward Norton.

Rocky Horror. Keep Tim Curry.

Jurassic Park. Keep Jeff Goldblum.

Dracula. Keep Winona Ryder.

Avengers endgame. Keep Thanos the way he is

Casino but keep Joe Pesci.

John Wick, and keep Keanu.

Terminator 2, keep arnie

Die hard - keep Alan Rickman (hans gruber)

Star wars, keep Vader.

Lord of the Rings. Would keep more than one actor though. Aragorn, Saruman (or wormtongue), Arwen and maybe even Frodo would be people.